Fattoria Pogni

Hotel Description

You know what caught me off guard about Fattoria Pogni? The moment you turn off the main road toward Marcialla and start climbing Via Pogni di Sopra, it actually feels like you’re driving into someone’s private world. I mean, this isn’t your typical Tuscan agriturismo that’s been sanitized for tourists – it’s the real deal, sitting up there at 159 like it’s been watching over the Chianti hills forever.

The property itself is honestly stunning in that understated way that only happens when a place has genuine history. The buildings have that weathered stone look that you can’t fake, and the grounds… well, they’re not manicured like some resort, but they’re beautifully maintained in a way that feels natural. What I loved most was how quiet it gets in the evenings – you’re far enough from Florence (maybe 45 minutes if you know the back roads) that there’s no city noise, just countryside sounds and the occasional church bell from one of the nearby villages. The rooms have this authentic farmhouse feel without being rustic to the point of discomfort, if that makes sense. Good Wi-Fi too, which honestly surprised me given how tucked away you are.

Here’s the thing about staying in Marcialla that most people don’t realize – you’re actually perfectly positioned for day trips but far enough out that you get to experience real Tuscan life. The locals at the little alimentari down the hill were genuinely friendly (not tourist-friendly, just… friendly), and there’s something to be said for waking up to actual farmland views instead of tour buses. The breakfast situation was particularly good – fresh everything, obviously, and they source a lot from their own property and neighboring farms. I’d honestly put this place up against any of the fancier options closer to San Gimignano, but here you’re getting authenticity and that 9.5 rating makes total sense once you’ve been there. The staff knows the area inside and out too, so they’ll steer you toward those hidden wine cellars and family-run trattorias that you’d never find otherwise. It’s not cheap, but it’s not trying to be – it’s just really, really good at what it does.

Rooms

• Estimated price from: $180. Apartment – Ground Floor with 1 large double bed and 1 sofa bed for Max persons: 4
• Estimated price from: $180. Studio Apartment with 1 large double bed and 1 sofa bed for Max persons: 4
• Estimated price from: $180. Apartment with Garden View with 1 large double bed and 1 sofa bed for Max persons: 4
• Estimated price from: $245. Two-Bedroom Apartment (4 Adults) with 2 × 1 large double bed and 1 futon bed for Max persons: 5
• Estimated price from: $257. Apartment with Pool View with 1 large double bed, 2 × 1 futon bed and 2 single beds for Max persons: 6
• Estimated price from: $257. Deluxe Apartment with 1 large double bed, 2 single beds and 1 sofa bed for Max persons: 6
• Estimated price from: $437. Deluxe Villa with 2 single beds and 4 × 1 large double bed for Max persons: 10

Reviews

• Stunning Tuscan Escape – Kelsie from Australia – 8 June 2025 (9/10)

  Fantastic breakfast, perfect place to stop and do nothing for a couple of days. Very comfortable apartment and staff were more than helpful, above and beyond.

• Exceptional – Nóra from Austria – 8 June 2025 (10/10)

  The property itself is beautiful, huge area with an infinity pool and place for some activities, even for children, there is a playground. Staff is very friendly and helpful. Breakfast is super nice, they offer salty and sweet bites too. You can charge your electric or hybrid car for free. A small but very enviromental friendly guesture is that you get glass bottles to refill them with water anytime you want.
  
  What could be improved: The bed was comfortable and clean but very squeaky. Literally every movement comes with a noise.

• Exceptional – Martin from Czech Republic – 3 June 2025 (10/10)

  Everything was amazing – nice place, kind stuff, very good wine. We would definitely love to come back.
  
  What could be improved: We were accommodated in an apartment that did not have a separate bedroom, although the Booking website stated otherwise. The bedroom was located on the upper floor, but without any separation from the rest of the accommodation. This was a problem for us, especially since we were traveling with a small child. Otherwise, the accommodation was beautiful.

• Couldn’t have been more perfect – Amanda from Australia – 2 June 2025 (10/10)

  Everything. There is nothing I could add to make this more perfect
  
  What could be improved: Nothing

• Very nice hotel in a beautiful area. – John from United States – 21 May 2025 (10/10)

  Beautiful property.
  
  What could be improved: Nothing.

• Beautiful place to stay in Tuscany – Francesca from United Kingdom – 18 May 2025 (10/10)

  Absolutely beautiful property, we loved our stay here. The staff are also brilliant, so helpful and friendly – we would highly recommend!

• However, it’s a great choice for larger groups, as it offers a spacious common area that’s perfect f – Tanja from Slovenia – 12 May 2025 (10/10)

  We had a wonderful stay at the villa this weekend! The location was absolutely dreamy – peaceful, scenic, and perfect for a relaxing getaway.
  
  The breakfast was tasty and varied, with plenty of options to choose from. If I had to mention one small thing, it would be that the selection leaned a bit more toward the sweet side; a bit more savory variety would have been a nice balance.
  
  What could be improved: The villa we stayed in had a bit of an old feel and a slight musty smell, likely due to the age of the building.

• A lovely family friendly stay. New mattresses would make it the ultimate stay – Jenelle from Australia – 27 April 2025 (8/10)

  Great facilities and helpful staff in the Tuscan countryside. We made use of the pool, tennis courts, table tennis and abundant outdoor seating areas. Rooms were spacious
  
  What could be improved: Uncomfortable beds and tennis racquets need upgrading

• Amazing, quiet location in a scenic area of Tuscany. – Carrie from United States – 25 January 2025 (10/10)

  So many wonderful things to say about the owner and staff- they were amazing and incredibly helpful, and thought of the little things to make travelling with a toddler amazing. I cannot stress how wonderful they all were!

• Comfortable and memorable 🙂 – Tze from Singapore – 6 December 2024 (10/10)

  Beautiful property with facilities to keep my 4 year old and older children entertained 🙂 breakfast was great and the staff were all so friendly and helpful!
  
  What could be improved: Nothing my family and I didn’t like.

SURROUNDINGS

Facilities